Picking up my hanging thread, of course my other fear is the closet. I used to think there were monsters in my closet, and for awhile, I was pretty sure it contained a vicious velociraptor, toe claw prepared to disembowel my impressionable young self. Blame Jurassic Park. But later, as I knocked all my childhood fears down (girls, clowns, Indian food), I discovered that all I had left to fear was painful death, STDs, heights, and my own latent bisexuality. I set off to Australia determined to conquer atleast two of those fears.
If you've been reading this blog as religiously as Dan, you'd know that Australia, besides incessant binge drinking and my constant attempts to find life-threatening animals, was all about homosexuality. I managed to make a slut of myself, and in a short amount of time, fool around with more guys than I had in my entire life to that point. I even managed to get myself outed, to become the token College Fag at St John's, a visible symbol and lightning rod to attract people's acceptance, homophobia, and everything in between. But it was never honest.
I accepted a moniker, a cloak of homosexuality if you will, because I needed to finally understand that part of me. I ultimately found that while being gay is easier to get laid, I found it no more fulfilling than being straight. Which I suppose means that I'm either practically asexual (ROFL!), am picky as hell, or most normally, fooling around is only so amusing, and I need a real connection and affection to really enjoy myself.
So, lesson learned. Now it was time to return to the real world, having broken down my fear of the closet and being labeled as gay by my peers. I was ready to be a whole person. I just needed to take a detour through New Zealand.
I didnt expect any gay people on this trip, and I wasnt wrong, though that didnt stop me from prodding a few potentials (not literally) to find out. What I didnt expect was Ruth. I'm attracted to girls all the time, but its been a long time since I've had a real crush, and here I was smacked hard in the face by one.
The two of us got along well enough, and the possibility did seem to linger in the air. Then Louise got suspicious. We had another man on our tour, the german with the complicated name, who was being visibly discreet (if you get my drift) about his private life. So Louise, our loveably gruff and forward big woman on the trip started grilling him from her cozy spot in the hot tub. I walked in at the wrong time.
"Scott, do you have a girlfriend?" she asked, to which I honestly responded 'no'. I knew, or thought I knew what she was getting at. She must've thought I was a sexless dork or something, which frankly wouldnt be a bad assumption under other circumstances. However, I didnt want to have to maintain an imaginary girlfriend, and Ruth was in the motel room with the open door, very much in hearing distance. Then, I was proven wrong.
"Scott, do you have a boyfriend?" My eyes must've bugged out. Shit, am I that obvious? Have I suddenly transformed into total camp? The expression on my face was happily more confusion than fear, because G-man stepped in and explained that he was getting the same treatment. So I answered Lou, an honest "no". But, the look on my face was a precrafted and manufactured combination of frankness and disdain, designed to say "I'm not a homophobe, but I'm no fucking queer!" It was a look I perfected in the closet, a place I found myself again.
I can tell you now with all honesty, I was not afraid of being out. I was not afraid of being hated, shunned, or beaten up. I could take whatever anyone threw at me. No, the one and only reason I stepped back from the edge was Ruth. Long ago I had come to the conclusion that no one likes a bi man. Guys think he's a cheater, while girls think he's diseased. Hell, the reason I adopted the mask of gay in Australia was because I didnt want to deal with the hassle of biphobia while experimenting. But my experiments were over, and this was supposed to be my return to the real world. Well, welcome to the real world. If I ever want to be with a girl again, I'd better keep my mouth shut.
Putting me in the closet is always a bad idea. When I started in Australia, the strain of trying to say in the closet while being sexually active the first month caused me to pointlessly out myself to the entire StudLife newspaper staff back home and almost publicly out myself to the entire school in an editorial piece. Luckily, my mom talked some sense into me in the last minute. She was right all along. Girls equate bi to gay, and I need to carefully control who knows about me. Now here I was in New Zealand, trying to do just the same, but with newfound queer identity pride gnawing at my mind the whole time. I became obsessive, thinking about outing myself almost all the time, knowing that nothing good would come of it. Something had to break.
It's always alcohol, isnt it? When you get drunk, things happen. In Wellington, my streaking was an intentional and carefully planned experiment, albeit one whose results depressed the crap out of me. No, my real alcoholic slip-up was when I quietly outed myself to Lou at a corner table. But she's a big girl. She must know what its like, how the reality of herself prevents her from getting everything she wants. Fuck, it must be so much harder for her, since there's no closet to hide in. I hope she doesnt read this, but if she does, I'm genuine when I say I have so much respect for her.
Anyhow, she agreed that girls usually dont like bi guys, but figured it was pointless anyway, since she believed Ruth and I were too platonic and going nowhere fast. If its causing me strain, I might as well be out.
Well, I didnt take her advice, keeping it bottled up for more of the trip. Luckily, we gained some new members in Wellington, including one named Ash. Now, for any of my tourmates reading this, allow me to put a rumor to bed, permanently. Ash is straight. Ash is entirely heterosexual. I'm the fag, not Ash. You guessed wrong.
Ash, besides being 50% older than me, was very much like me. He was chatty, goofy, highly extroverted, and seemed to always be hiding his depths behind a thick but shallow mask. Hopefully I got atleast a glimpse behind it. But, more relevantly to the story, I realized right away I could talk to him. Perhaps more importantly, he's a lighting director for concerts and plays, and must have a high fag tolerance as part of the job requirement. So in Christchurch, without me even being too pissfaced, I outed myself to him too.
The irony of the whole situation was that we had our long philosophical chat sitting at the hotel (shitty dirty hostel) bar. I had no qualms talking about homosexuality surrounded by drunken and potentially hostile strangers, but I couldnt say a peep around Ruth or the rest of the tour. However, Ash could see I looked visibly relieved releasing some of the pressure, and he said as such. But, he also made the point that as much as I claim its all about Ruth, the fact remains that this is a matter of shame to me. I can pretend to be GAY all I want, but unless I can synthesize some pride in being BI, I'll never be happy with myself.
That hurt. I had pride in my newfound pride, but he was right. That shouldve settled the matter, but it only made it worse. So its no surprise this issue reared its ugly head again next time I got shitfaced. Queenstown this time. An even more drunken man came up to me without warning, grabbed my arms, and started dancing with me. To be fair, I was pretty unattracted to him, but my my reluctance, my limp posture, my rolled eyes and sour face, all consciously constructed. He wizzed off obliviously to go dancing with a girl, and almost immediately, Scissor Sisters came on. Gleefully, I cozied up to Emma to dance, expressing my strong liking for the group and secretly wishing someone would tell me that they're gay.
We didnt all make it to the next bar. The ratio was pretty highly skewed towards guys. But somehow, we all managed to position ourself with geometric exactness in ways that we all danced in the direction of one of our rare women. It frustrated the hell out of me. What if I wanted to dance with a man? I quietly raved to Lou, as Ash was long gone, but she could only offer my sympathy and the chance to dance with her as a cover. Soon, she too went to bed, as did everyone else, and it was only left to me and Hannah.
Walking back to the hotel, I outed myself to Hannah as well, but she could only tell me that she was right, that she wouldnt want to hook up with a bi guy. She feared that she'd never be enough, that even if they werent gay-in-denial, they'd still never be satisfied. I assured her that this was only her own self-doubt speaking, that cheaters are cheaters and it doesnt depend on sexuality. She agreed with me, on an intellectual level, but reminded me of the obvious: Relationships are never about logic. Regardless of what she knows, she'll always feel inadequate, and she couldnt maintain a relationship like that. Then she went to bed.
Pissed and pissed, there was no way I could go to sleep. I wandered back to town, the the only bar apparently still open. Inside, I started chatting with strangers, talking my problems with girls I'd never met before. I had no intention of hooking up with them, so it was no problem. At one point, a big towering man grabbed me by the scruff of my collar and threateningly asked me if I was hitting on him. I wasnt, but it didnt matter. I was drunk and queer and I didnt care. My eyes had no fear, so he dropped me and went back to drinking.
With the clock breaking 4 and twilight starting, I made for my bed, but only managed to make it to the lobby phone. I called home with my credit card, easily the stupidest decision I made in the entire country. My mom didnt have anything soothing to say to me. I used to think she didnt understand bisexuality, always asking me when I was going to pick sides because she couldnt wrap her mind around a grayscale. Now I knew she understood it better than me; I could be as gray as I want, but I'll be gray and alone. I dont necessarily need to pick a side in who I sleep with, but I need to define myself in a neat little box or walk around with this anxious self-doubting baggage the rest of my life. I went to bed that night firmly in a new closet, and $100 in international calls down the hole. No surprise I overslept hang gliding.
This new closet was quite comfortable, and I could hit on girls in peace, knowing that the only gay guys I may meet yet wont be on tour. Essentially, I was living the Down Low, something I deeply hated a few days earlier. I suppose now I understand bisexual guys who get married and have kids, but fuck guys through the personal ads behind her back. He wanted a normal life with a wife and kids, and were he to be honest with himself, he'd be stuck with the undesirable life of a marginalized gay activist. He wanted warm American Pie, and I cant blame him for that. But it's also something I couldnt maintain myself. The new closet lasted without cracks for approximately 2 days.
Milford Sound, as you already know, is gorgeous. A perfect backdrop to get shitted on cheap champaign and play Cranium. Homosexuality never even came up, but I snapped. Luckily, Ash was handy to scoop me up and deposit me outside before I made any lasting damage. We stayed up for hours, chatting on top deck with the mountains and glaciers silhouetted in the dark. With his hoodie on, he looked like silhouetted Grim Reaper himself. I dont think I'll soon forget the image of Death among the mountains, asking me to choose.
Our long talk didnt stay confined to bisexuality, though I selfishly always tried to steer it back. No, the topics ranged wide, and burrowed themselves deep into my unconscious psyche. Sure, perhaps that sounds like I'm saying "I dont remember what we said", and that wouldnt be entirely false, but I do remember the feelings it gave me. More importantly, I remember what I learned, which may sound obvious in retrospect. If I cant be honest with myself, I cant be happy. If I'm with someone, girl or guy, and I cant be honest to them or myself, it'll never work. This new closet may be designed to make working relationships, but it will ultimately destroy them all. It's only human nature to care about what others think, to want to be perceived 'just right'. We all have our own masks and closets; its simply part of how we interact with each other. The problem is when it hurts.
The next night was our last, at Lake Ohau. Perfect excuse for a toga party, and my last chance with Ruth. Needless to say, that went nowhere. Ruth and I also have alot of similarities in our personalities, which is why my last real moment of the tour was the three way (conversation) between myself, Ruth, and Ash at dinner. But that's irrelevant to this story. Far more pertinent was that Ruth was all over the dance floor, having a good time with everybody. She was here to have fun, and that's all she was here for. She enjoyed my company because I could be as extroverted and funny as here, but she was never going to be with me, or anyone else on the trip. Lou was right. Alittle disappointing perhaps, but a fairly fitting ending. She was the engine that let me learn that I wasnt done discovering myself after Australia.
One last surprise awaited me. Lorna sat at the bar, chatting up the bartender. Jokingly, I told her she should get his number... that is, his room number! I thought I was pretty funny shit, but she totally misinterpreted me. She blinked, confused, then asked in hushed tones "Scott, are you gay?!"
Well, I really didnt see that one coming. I stepped back, shocked, and exclaimed "Not for me, for you!!" She seemed satisfied with this response, but I wasnt. Instead, I leaned in and said "But good call, you were half right" with a smirk. A smile broke across her face. We spent the rest of the evening drinking colorful but disgusting shooters like a "Cocksucking Cowboy" and "Podocarpus" [a genus of Australian conifers, wtf?] and sizing up the boys around us. I hadnt done that since leaving Australia, and god it felt good!
She also told me she thinks bi guys are hot, but nothing came out of that. Still, amused the crap out of me. Maybe 1/4 girls find it irresistible. Good odds?
Two more people got their final say that night. Ash pulled me aside before he went to sleep to share a last secret with me. He'd alluded to being smitten by a girl on tour, but I had no idea it was Lorna. But, cest la vie, it didnt work out. However, the moral of that side story, if I wasnt too drunk to misinterpret it, was that people arent always like their first impressions. If we're all open, our true selves will eventually shine through, or atleast be pieced together from behind our masks. That's the only way I'll find someone genuine for me.
On the other hand, Lou simply said "I've seen how you've been on this tour. You cant care so much about what people will think about you. I dont." If I'd followed her advice from the beginning, how would this tour have been different?
The last bus trip back was a sad one. Gifts were given, awards were given ("We're going streaking!"), and tears were shed. They asked us all to come to the front of the bus, get on the microphone, and say what they loved the most about the trip. Sitting in the very back seat, I expected to go last. Too bad Jenn pulled a fast one on me. We're going backwards order, and I was first.
Walking down the green mile to the front of the bus, I wondered what was most memorable. The seal swim was pretty damn cool. Hang gliding was unexpectedly pleasant. Skydiving was simply unforgettably awesome, and the U-Fly airplane was a once-in-a-lifetime experience. I acknowledged them as such, but I told a simple truth:
"You probably expect me to say the coolest moment was the Canyon Swing or the U-Fly, and frankly, you'd be right. Thanks Jenn and Erin for the recommendations. But those arent my favorite or most memorable moments. No, what I'll remember the most was the discussions... oh, stop laughing! It's true! I'm going to remember the conversations I've had, the philosophical, the advice, even just the pleasant chatting, against the most beautiful backdrops like Milford, Queenstown, and Lake Ohau. That's what I needed, and that's what I'll remember the most. People, you know who you are. Thank you."
Atleast, that's how I think it went. I might've been stuttering and mumbling too much. You probably expected me to publicly and extravagantly out myself on a pedestal at the last moment, but then you wouldve missed the entire point. Grand declarations are just as fraudulent as manufactured facial expressions. Neither is natural. If I want to really be happy, I cant be gripped by a need to lie or a compulsion to out myself. I dont need to worry about what girls are pro or anti bi. I dont even need to tell every casual acquaintance or one night stand. I just need to be honest.